C. Expels Albert Goldman Perspectives for American Labor olicy answer for the Tre of conveni of the impending calamity. It gives theoretical justification against any a speaker for the Friends of the rainer viewed himself as a potent. the We are led to believe that as bad as they are at this to and PAGE THE MILITANT SATURVAY, JULY 8, 1933 united front has as its main purpose the involving of large masses of workers of different oragnizations in a struggle against the capitalist class on the basis of an immediate issue. further stated my that the main purpose of our par. Continued from Page 1) Igle sentence in anything wrote Communist Party. In short, Although American capitalism is ixtie poles. They are becoming take place now. But all phases of ental. was opposed to the joining or to joint to any statement that criticism of the method of calling liamentary cammign should be the entering, or has entored, the up aware that a rise in productivits the business cycle Iull, average of the Scottsboro issue with the mundo, indicating that detend the Congress was that it was calleducation of the workers in the wart swing of a new cycle. It is does not necessarily result in a coroduction, boom and crisis. from descending curve in contraddistinc chance at the Congres to explain tcrnational. have sold many xation, whereas it should have can bext be done at the Communistetives of the near future point share of the national profit.
my position. The sotning of the things about the united front and been called by a provisional com rty has its own candidates and to growing radicalization of the to this the fact that a cyclication to a formerly ascending one.
two issues in such a mechanical about the German situation which mittee representing all tendencies conducts its campaign on its own American man while it might com as it the late restoration of the depressed Trainer detectors webis the premanner was harmful Loth to the were in argument with Trotsky in the labor movement. This very Patform that united front for Mooney issue and to the Scottsboro idues. do not apologize for that, idea was advocated by the party the purpose of clecting someone to Onited States stands as a rulutation American standard of living and it sout stage of development of the the ones who ism. did not altogether exclude it possesses both the most highly ing process will continue. relationships of world imperialism the party had been asked to at that one must first find out what gress. said Labor power is a commodity. As Boone will be extremely short tend the fruction meeting and given Trotsky has said, and then say the called the Congress thought of the the wsibility of a united front on developed forms of the capitalist te chance to make my position Sicar. cxact opposite? The claim is con united front tactic as something the parliamentary, tic, but very mode of production and the least such its true value is determined lived and succeeded by crises of Baterie de compromision made to eletne stantly made that Trotsky was which permits one organization to severels criticied the tactics as for near the best developed resw the value of the physical min unusual length and depth. Continued in next issue)
The violation of discipline at the expelled for violation of discipline invited all other organizations Why then deliberately lie in at this contradiction is no refutation reproduce that labor power from Mooney Congress was but the pre and not for his ideas. If that is its affair. One organization de various so, and am not naive enough to cides to have a congress or a hun tributing to me as the reason for at all. On the contrary, it can be day to day plus certain require problems confronting the American Believe it is it not possible to cermarch or what it and then opticiamentare hetSometerstood to its fullest extent only ones dictated by natural condi. Parliamentary Cretinism movement and the world movement are with Trotsky and still be a graciously sends an invitation all other organizations to join it. The workers already support dit the larger content of Marxism. level of the United States. How (Cont. 1)
and such that condict between party member?
myself and the party leadership In the course of a discussion with is to make all organizations for Why sive the absolutely false The political lag of the American ever, by reason of its bring a com lity, labor power is amenable to barbusse paper, Monde) are keepwas inevitable. If the party jer the District Committee on my that they are participating in the impression that my oposition to working class is the result of pee the invisible laws govering all ing watch over you! Aud, as if to Harities of national development. In mitted freedom of discussion, that views. explicitly stated that do contlict would run its natural not consider Cannon and Lovestone calling of the united front confer the Workers Ticket was based on the TN the sciousness of the commodities. It is influenced by complete the picture of colitical de course within the. of discipline is inevitable breach of that opinion. By virtue of what have been able to swing many more polley to the appeal to the mem to a certain level as a result oring forced below or carried above scriats leading article on out froklom of discussion present relations between Ger rule in the party or the Commun Socialist party locals and Ameri. hers of the American Federational Names of American econ. its true value according as Labor locals Labor and Socialist Party; to mic development only to subside available supply of labor power is. de tent. Tew. com typical example of the dishonesty expulsion for itch an opinion? Ifway from the reactionary lender join with the Communist Party in under the influence of a subsequent above or below demand. But with ary philistine relates that for the a typical example of the dishonesty Int International is one liable to can Federation of uriod of comparative prosperity. the tremendous technological adarst ume. in the relations of that characterized the district cight there is such a rule, let it be made hip. The criticism war levelled the chection struggles. leaders in my whole conflict with blic immediately!
fense Committee and not a word have only one reason. To discre with the opportunity the rom there exists a permament and re course to reprisuls against Austria them. There is practically not a In what way did slander the latively growing over supply of to force measures internal single, whole sentence in the state Communist arty of Germany? By was said about the Communist dit with the workers who will never ler and the possibilities of indivibor power. While a cyclical re rom that government. For the party.
et a chance to road my reply to al escape from the working class ment which is not either a down. tying that its united front tactics right distortion of the facts or were incorruet Let me call atII. 3) He did not participate in means of a limited success as a Twould cause them to rise irst time in the relations of the concludes wilful misinterpretation, Wilful Misinterpretations any mass activity, and abstained slonal min) operates a safety as a result of the absorption of a with the following remarkablo claiming that there is a sharp lindtention to the fact that when the party leaders were grandiloquently of demarcation between a plain mis proclaiming that the Communist. that there can be no united confining his activity to that of a American wrotetaritasse politicat Tower, from that point they would dermany and Austria bure never statement of fact or, in plainer Party of Germany will crush the front unorganized workers, lawyer, appearing in a number of fuctor in the social life of Amert once more recede.
Deell, since the existence of the English, a downright lie) and an Fascists. was warning everyone therefore laying down a light wing cases in court, and occasionally as can capitalism. The American wage Thus Theriod of prosperity existing moment. Such is the practical reence, will deal with these two me no satisfaction whatever to say activities in the shops where the Soviet Union.
types of falschols under different that was right. The real truth masses of workers are unorganiz. do not of course claim that ber of the working ial capitalist rather than as a mem between 1923 and 1920, as far as suit of Hitler foreign policy.
headings.
Cluss. His workers are concerned, basomewhat u bepalehe of the matter is that when one ed.
did the most important work in ideology was that of the retty still never to return. It is est read this philosophy The answer do not assume to criticizes the leaders of the party, real gem of logic, worthy of the party. did not organize any bourgeois and le failed to recogmata that improvement of product worthy of a conservative Privatenter into a detailed explanation of it is called slander; and when the the leaders of district eight: How artymis, nor did organize any in the desirability of acting as tive technique has progressed to the dozen. professor. Hitler Icon the various problems which dis party leaders slander everyone who the conclusion follows from the unemployed councils or industriala mass.
point where a return to the produc ducting a policy of counter revolucussed in articles and speeches disagrees with them, it is called premise is a mystery which only mions. But the statement above It criticism.
the logicians of district cight can quoteel leaves the impression that conditions whicrenliar historicaltion levels of 1928 23, which istionary realism in Austria. He wins But today the not likely, could be made today with over the pretty surgeois mass by the phil confines itself merely to a simple handled very few (1) Ile developed theory solve.
the re employment of not more than dining the ground from under un denial and a short explanation of The statement made in an arti practically nothing cases and did sophy of individualism so deeply Treent of the 16 million Amerintable Austrian Bonapartism. With elve besides.
all the distortions contained in the that only a united front with leadcle which was not published for For the last four years have into the minds of the American can workers unemployed at present. untimacy and perseverance, Hitler ers is possible.
workers are no longer statement present.
What a shameful untruth! One one reason or other, but which the handled very few cases and did They are succumbing, or have suc la period of cyclical recovery with forees in his favor. He does not Thus, the United States will enter is changing the relationship of must lose all hope in the possibil. district eight bureaucrats mis practically nothing else besides.
ity of successful Communist quoted and misinterpreted was that for the last four years have development. The frontier is clos army of at least million personer the traininthe distinguishes etmhed, to the march of economica permament industrial reserve of relations with DISTORTIONS OF FACT Dollfuss. In (1) He (Goldman) was pre mement when leaders can stoop the united front presupposed the hatched ibundred bort et sanse for the cd. No longer is it possible chor Party workers and distinguishes himselt his opposition to the policy of the tunately we understand very well. on fundamental principles, but were times when appeared in to rise out of their class liy become contrary, it is reasonable to pre to his Stalinist bureauCommunist Party in the Trade that the Communist movement is agreding to act together on some court every day for weeks Unions.
only temporarily burdened with immediate Issue; that the necessary weeks. spoke at least an average in small farmers or by entering the pose its further growth. The ad ft Orto Bauer permanently overcrowded ers will continue. Each year an lations between Austria and Ger was never expelled from the Nieh leaders who depend upon attempts to organize the inorgan. of three times a week, hefre disons. The small farm proftechnological displacement of work cracy which does not view the reperty for that reason or any other lies and repression for their con ied workers around some immediferent branches of various organi recured to the economie status of all ined working age will gwell class struggle but from the standhas been indlux of young persons who have many from the standpoint of reason. was not od to the can say is, where and when aid et imagination be considered a unithe trol of the Communist party. All ate issue would not by any stretch zations. do not say this with any feeling crican schools and colleges are take it, all in all, it may be said the hoor wasant of Europe. Am the ranks of available workers. So point of diplomatie eretinism.
the trade unions, during the years or write anything Justifying ted front. Where, then, does the that did a lot for the movement, turning out thosands of young that the American period of high Paris Congress called to replace policy of the Communist party in idea that there should be no actir. but simply to show the dishonesty pre trained for professional wages is a thing of the past.
Moscow enthusiasın for the this wlander?
1920 25 when was active in the (5) He persistently resisted the ities in the shops come from? Askcontained in the above statement service for whom there is no em the revolutionary struggle in Ausunderground party. was opposed independent role of the party in the the leadership of district eight of the secretariat.
ployment. The possibility of a suc In 1929 the United States define tria, and the indignation at Basle III. as a small merchant has been rely joined Europe in a condition over the policy of Hitler who does of the united front from above with Pederation of Laobr or the Socialist stitutes a leaders of those days in their actis itical criticism of the American workers to one of our dances con It freedom of discussion were to reduced to the neighborhood of zero of general capitalist. decline. Its not fear, in the struggle against Hullman Levine gong of the Party leaders.
Negro and white workers struggle XING in the firty had been given of capital neechisary to start in export of enpital between 1923 29. Dollfuss hine, to dispute with inite front that when by a rise in the minimum amount industrial activity, held up by the the Austrian there is no aniAmalgamated Clothing Workers, did not object to political critic. together, it is a united front and oportunity to talk to the memisines for oneself and by the permanently slackened. The gen mal stronger than a cat. sus the tactie which, at that time, killed bership on the various problems the Left wing in the Amalgamated ism, but did object to vile and will probably furnish you with sim that and which to large extent ex stupid attacks which had the inevitilar examples of their conception two as raised in my articles: had invasion of large scale capital (with eral crisis of capitalism laid it by mouse this atstum and this which wrote dealing its superior technique, greater con the heels and today America is con indignation complement cach other trol over sources of supply and fronted plains its pitiable weakness at probable result of alienating all the of a united front. Can we not, with the united front on the parlia imilar Advantages into such pls capital seeking investment, ex diplomatie ed by an accumulation of sur as two forms of parliamentary and sent.
non party ople from 19.
held and with the slogan judged. In with events of that perica, insa muted national, he interpreted as agree to attend classes in the B of lished; bad felt that the district. 1929 it maste a total of 21. per poly profits, restricted markets and termine the sickness by a symptom, leaders were honestly opposed to me cent of all retail other phenoment characteristic of These two articles are enough obvious. Undoubtedly the secret(2) He aso developed a Lattist: ut were willing to permit me to workers are beginning to realize However, this does not mean that Rundschau to say perhaps the At the same time, the period of capitalist decay. one in Pravda, the other in the This charge is exceedingly humorarlat accepted the word of that igfront discuss norant confusionist par excellence, ons. did not, as a matter of theory against the united Robert Minor. It was he who ask fact, make that claim. How could campaign of the Communist party them all the vital sues before that their interests and those of the cyclical variations are excluded. On Centrist bureaucracy has adequate membership. would now feel vexed at myself for my pensive halls in Paris and to publeadership at the 1042 Amalgamated lion was that we should criticize that in the elections there can be breach of discipline at the Mooney lish bulky papers in Basle, but BuNazis Cut Wages reaucratie Centrism as a revolumost completely taken in by the the basis of the issues involved in since the workers already support pulsion would have been merited tionary current is dead, it decom.
shrewd and slippery Hillman. It the particular united front action, different political parties. He but would feel that almost any (Continued from Page 1)
was he who fought me bitterly at whereas the Communist Interna sharply opposed the policy of the other punishment would be well dd (Continued from Page 1)
proses before our eyes and polsons is after this anti Soviet speech: In cuts, so that they could not partithe atmosphere.
the fraction meeting of the com tionat came out with its advice Workers Ticket charging that served. Communist discipline TROTSKY.
quent to the convention. There was from criticism? It seems that meal to the members of the Ameri. seriously. But when Communist we thank the Archbisbop meetings took place on the same. rinkipo, June 13, 1933.
dictate him and Hillman against the Lett spinion that my position was en minnist Peaty tin the world in the course the boscositus: it hassumes a formal Hieromouk Dinitri for being pre against the wall of the mentale moved from the ideas of Commun lowed hand shaklogs between the lengthened, at holy alliance, Minor took advantage tional, and to counteract that oplngles.
of the vicions trame up of Hillman ton, the district leaders attributed What a jumble of misrepresen. Ist discipline as taught by Lenin. two counter revolutionary Everyone knew was a delegate guards and the two Friends. Continued from Page 1)
and Levine against in on the basis it to ma of which was expelled from thel (7) At the Free Tom Booney article which wrote on the sub to the Mooney Congress, am quite the Soviet Union. Dr. Le Roy and Jews was exposed most Here the struggle against the we can more successfully attack Amalgamated as a spy clearly. the rest of the world.
Congress he made a speech in Sect been published, could casily betting that the fact that was a Freeman Sarcastic laughter This shop belongs to an enormous Rumors pointing the finger of which he held the Communist Party refer the reader to it and the delegate reached the ents of the greeted this very dignified ceremony English Jewish concern. Since this To help cover up the real policies suspicion against me began to be finise Committee responsible cireninted in the party two years berice of delegates from the so. was not published, so that all the would be settled. But the article Congress convenedl. Why was Il German shop as a result of the concentrated attack on internaOpen air meetings conducted by seasonal summer slackness and the title markets. they Net not fuvited to the traction meeting the Leet Opwition are systematie allegedly excessive wages. could utopian nationalistic ideal of high after everyone knew about the calist Party.
can do is to give its leading ideas where should have been given a ully broken up by the staliuksts no bring a return on the capital prices, stabilized for a generation, frame up and during which time I did not say word about the last said in that article that the courage to present my views on the while a clos enemy is given all invested by the English Jews, Go of a nationally managed currency, was very active in the underground conduct of the Congress and on the opportunities to express anti Soviet Geremtenice employees and work of broader purchasing tower for the party. demanded an immediate investigation, and refrained from boro and Mooney issue? On the party controlled organization. Left the struggle against Jewish finance of improved conditions for agricul activity in the meantime. com.
one hand, am kept out of the oppositionists are being expelled, capital loks in practice. Two Fapture as against industry, of a genmittee to investigate was appointed, fraction meeting and on the other not only from the party but also lish Jews with a fortune of hun tod of 1924 19:25. The realities, and not until the united front beby hand, if say anything contrary from auxiliary organizations by the dreds of millions of marks and a however, are not stabilization but eral return to the prosperous pertween Minor and Hillman was to the decision of the fraction, same leaders who broken up did the commitee come violate discipline. Heads win White Guard Wrangelites. The Aryan origin, who, piled up a huge stimulation of agriculture, but the German capitalist out with a statement branding the tails you lose!
the wildest speculation; not the action of Hillman and Lovine as a Y, violated discipline, but unorer these facts.
earnest Communist must frameup to get me out of the AmON GERMANY der the circumstances expulsion is farmer. the war in England and did not elimination of the small algamated. was then studying Party members should demand an have to give up a single penny of the masses Purchasing power for not justified, and since expulsion explanation from their leadership. it (probably because he was a brave power due to intiation and The ONLY ROAD WHAT NEXT?
law and did not go back to party was decided upon, it is obvious Instead of repudiating this affair German front soldier. get their tying up of the trade unions, hand but less purchasing 35 activity, but was never expelled.
192 pages paper cover 100 pages the that the real reason is not my con the Daily Worker has maintained money at the expense of the work and foot, with the ropes of the (2). Goldman at that time Postage 06 extra per copy cloth over Postage 06 extra per copy the fact that for the past six (during the united front conference held in October 1932 in Chicago)
months or so have dared to come there are any) should demand an is the Nazi program in its purest elements in the if assed in the meanest fashion. That Tudustrial Recovery Act defended the leaders of the Social.
ON RUSSIA out with theories of the united front accounting from their leadership form. The capitalist, whether Jew with sentimental hypocrisy, of ruth The combination of open force ist Party against the Communist PROBLEMS OF THE DEVELOPMENT OF Party position Price. 15 Postage. 01 extra per copy the German situation not to the for this shameful basiness.
or Christian, must live. The pro less driving toward a fixed goal After a stupid and violent atliking of the district cight leader. The Left opposition most, sharp letariat can starve.
with apparent vacillation, of an tack on Borders and the Socialist ON SPAIN ship ly condemns this dangerous inBut all these glories will not last open splitting of the London conParty leadership by Williamson of cannot deny that expulsion famous stunt and the attitude of long. Already a ferment is beginference with pious attempts to keep the Communist Party, an attack THE SPANISH REVOLUTION IN DANGER would be a terrible blow. No real the party lenders, who which alienated all the rank and Price. 15 Postage. 01 extra per copy Communist would take expulsion silence share the resposibility for conscious proletariat, but even in contribution to the technique of Alle of the non party organizations, from the party calmly. On the it. The depths of stalinist degen middle class cireles which until reaggressive imperialism.
ON THE TRADE UNION QUESTION was called upon to make a colother lection speech. stated that for COMMUNISM AND SYNDICALISM readers the most cherished posses: inal episode which this crim cently celebrated Hitler with en one, would accept the Socialist Price. 15 Postage. 01 extra per copy sion of a revolutionist, intellectual tomatic, makes the fight of the the dissatisfaction of the diapleaders who came into the united honesty and independship and in policies of Lenin and Trotsky more expression. Most often in and inte. LeftOpposition for a return to the pointed masses is finding frequent front at their word, and would ON THE THEORY OF SOCIALISM IN ONE COUNTRY this tellectual hoesty should never con necessary. more imperative criticize them only on the basis of AND THE PERMANENT REVOLUTION than way. To hell with Hitler, to hen COMRADE MILICENT SHOOTER their action in the united front flict. If there is a contitet if the ever before.
with the damned leaders of the We have received the sad news. KAMIAT.
struggle. In an article in the THE STRATEGY OF THE THE PERMANENT workers parties, the social dem from abrond that one of the first discussion within the limits of ocrats and the Communists, and the supporters of the left Opposition December issue of The Communist, WORLD REVOLUTION REVOLUTION (an article which was not listed in Communist discipline, if a party trade unions, who have betrayed us the table of contents, and which 180 pages paper cover member must conceal his views in and sold us out. Something else in England, comrade Millicent They in our ranks who errone has got was printed immediately after Wi Postage 06 extra per copy cloth cover 00 order to remain in the party, the to come. Leaders like Shooter, passed away at her home Postage. 06 extra per copy liamson reply all for the expulsion is no longer a disgrace, only act along the line of a bellut Lenin and Trotsky, that what we in Helston, pur: but a badge of honor.
pose of giving as little prominenin the existence of a basic contra need. Then we ll be there. Then Shooter rallied to The Militant Cornwall. Comrade ce to it as possible) developed ON CHINA Woe to the party that must re. diction betw bourgeois dem God rascals from all my position and criticized my own with contributions, both PROBLEMS OF sort to repression and expulsion to ocracy and Fascism, between the campus.
THE literary CHINESE REVOLUTION compel members to agree with the Social Democracy and Hitler hesitating cautions, unclear. That tion. We wish to record our ap statement. refer everyone That is what one hears, stin and financial, from its very Incep 450 pages paper cover 100 cloth cover 50 this article which will give the le leadership! Has it come to such a party, are harmful and fatal to the is the beginning. Now our work preciation at the excellent Jimmy Postage 06 extra per copy to the statement that defended TWENTY TWO stage in the Communist movement? is our chiet danger. Manuilsky: Communist movement. Indeed this is commencing.
the leaders of the Socialist Party.
My expulsion indicates that it has. Report at the XI Plenum of the IN THE NEXT ISSUE limit of her Higgins work she carried on to the (3) On the occasions he defended the position of the Second Intercapacity in Great the Central Committee of the party International, number 16, April will contain an article by comrado a faithful comrade in arms, who renational and that of the counterPIONEER PUBLISHERS will prove conclusively that there is 1931, page 703. the Militant Britain and our deep griet at losing revolutionary renegade, Trotsky.
84 EAST 10th STREET, He slandered the Communist Party no room for a thinking revolution FROM LENINISM VERSUS Trotsky in reply to the crities of mained with us to her last day.
ist within the party.
of Germany.
the History of the Russian Revolu ALBERT GOLDMAN.
STALINISM tion. challenge anyone snd a sinwhere. so the schood reas que committee of the communist Intere similare meaders could be compelled workeria organizations been so distribution to such an extent that som an expectation of high mononny cases one can precisely de. Archbishop and white workers, to six days.
up not. 63 duct at the Mooney Congress, but complete silence in. 25 the to