Part THE MILITANT Saturday, May 10, 1930 Doonping on China And the Kulak?
ry, because says our feeble minded Marxist. In the Soviet Union the remnants feudalism dominate the economic life of China, like the remnants of Doonping Kud Min Tangism dominate his thin Marxist veneer. This can mean Charlatanism as a Cover for the Concealment of Adventurism nothing but a repitition of the debacle of Hankow. For what else will this demoMOSCOW There is no other way to charact Stalin raised the slogan of Soviets cratic revolution look like? What will be its In a recent number of Soviet Siberia erize the article The Rising Revolutionary for China only after the crushing of the state form? What class will direct it?
one finds a decision of tbe Executive ComWave and Trotsky Liquidation in China Chinese proletariat and peasantry, after What will be its social program? Not mittee of the Regional Soviet where, among by Doonping it. the March issue of the the physical annihilation of the Chinese word about this. To speak of the democratother things, it says: Kulak holdings des Communist than as charlatanty and Communist Party to his ally Chiang Kal ic revolution after Nanking, after Hankow, tined to be liquidated are divided into two falsehood. It is not a polemical contribu Shek, because he could not and cannot dis. and particularly after thexperiencesgroups: The active Kulaks, among the tion written by someone convinced of his tinguish the face of a revolution from its negative though they were of the Canton richest, who must be deported to distant point of view right or wrong or of a con rump. The Opposition, polnting out only Soviet which proclaimed the socialist die.
localities, and all the remaining Kulaks fused revolutionist. but a piece of cheap what idiots and blind men cannot see that tato ship, is to place a legal prohibition who will be left within the limits of their slander, bought and paid for. That it can the counter revolution has triumphed in upon the Chinese proletariat to fight for respective districts but who will be put out disgrace the pages of even so rotten a re China has raised the slogan of the con power and lay the basis for a recurrence and distributed over other grounds outside view as the Communist is a pitiable com stituent assembly for China as a transt. of the crimes of Stalinism in the Chinese of the limits of the collective farms. This mentary on the theoretical abyss into which tional slogan that will revive the mags revolution of 1925 27. liquidation of the Kulak by means of Stalinism is dragging our movement, struggle and lead to issue of the third Chinese revolution, to the dictaDoonping Defense of Browder Article 58 and by administrative measure What Should Not Be Forgotten reminds me of the plan of the late Stamtorship of the proletariat which supports Two more words on Doonping. He ar bulisky. peasant prime minister of BulWhen a supporter of the Stalinist politself upon the masses of peasants. dently defends Earl Drowder from our garla killed by th3 fascists) to uproot enIcies in China dares to proclaim and deThis criminal record of the official ap.
comrade Charlie Bryne, who in an issue of tirely the Communist evil by means of a fend them publicly against the views conparatus must never be forgotten.
the Militant, once called Browder Stalin complete deportation of all the Bulgarian firmed a thousand times over of the Op.
Yankee Priest in China. Comrade Bryne Communiste (at that time they counted position, at the same time spewing big Now for Mr. Doonping dishon ust ar spoke more truly than he spoke, And here about 38, 000) to the desert Islands of the blanders upon Trotsky, who was chiefly reticle. His two main contentions are that 19 the fact When the nationalist goy Black Sea littoral or to any other kind of sponsible for shaping a course towards Bol Trotsky sees no revolutionary perspective ernment left Canton for Wuhan, the gen deserted locality. As you see, in this field shevism in China, It is first of all necessary in China. e. that he is a Iquidator. eral LI TI Sin carried out a coupd Etat in also our Centrists steal their ideas from to repeat a number of plain facts, which all and that China still stands before a bour Canton (December 1926 January 1927. others, in this case from a petty bourgeois the squirming of the bureaucrats will never geois democratic revolution, e. not be The workers were disarmed. The Canton prime minister of Bulgaria.
down: fore the dictatorship of the proletariat. Committee of the Kuo Min Tang, led by Staljn Bucbarin Martinoy were the Now how does Doonping draw the Left wing elements, was dissolved at bay.
Voronezh versus Tomsk!
principal props for Chlung Kal Shek until onet point. The workers groups that proNow for some news.
conc usion that Trotsky sees no revolutionThe leaders and the very last moment. The Opposition deary perspective in China? Because the tested were hunted down mercilessly and semi leaders of the capitulators have been manded that the Communists break with theoretical root o Trotsky mistakes is driven into illegality. Yet, after this redistributed throughout the On this Chiang Kai Shek and warned in advancehis erroneous theory of permanent revo actionary action, the delegation of the Comsubjected, Radek has reflected thus: Sure.
not after the fact, Doonping, but in advance lution. So Trotsky is an advocate of the intorn, composed of Browder, Tom Mann ly D. will exclam: Let Radek tell us now against his certain betrayal.
and Doriot, visited Canton, were received which is better Tomsk or Voronezh! Ah! Stalin and Co, srbordinated the Com. permanent revolution. that is, of the democratic revolution developing into the by the butcher LI TI Sin, and were banit must be admitted that D. was right munist Party to Chiang Kai Shek and the queted and toasted by him without a word in his foresight. But what can you do.
socialist revolution, of the flow of the class Kuo Min Taug. Under Stalin, the Chinese struggle rising steadily towards a higher of the meekest protest from them against There is no way out, no way out.
Communist Party, in a written document and broader stage. It that is true( and it the slaughter of workers. That is the beThree deported Oppositionists were arpledged itself not to criticize Sun Yat ginning and the end of Browder revolurested at Schtchedrinsk. They are accused 18) where does his quidationism. his Senism. Under Stalin, the Chinese Iack of revolutionary perspective fte tiosary record in China.
of having received directives and ot declared that it had differences only in spreading them. Quite simply, they are matters of detail with the bourgeois Kuo in? Doonping intimates that it is demon.
And now, who is Doonping himself that threatened with solitary for strated in Trotsky opposition to the sloving corMin Tang. Under Stalin the Chinese Comhe prasumes to teach Marxism and Leninism responded with comrades in a spirit which gan of Soviets at the present period, his munist Party was made to obey the disto Trotsky and the Opposition? He began is not that of the capitulators. With such cipline and decisions of the bourgeois opposition to the guerrilla warfare en.
his revolutionary education in a Chinese an accusation, the Centrists can arrest the dorsed by the stalinista, in his advocacy of bourgeois university, and improved it as The Opposition demanded in time, not alwhole population of the deportees. Moretransitional democratic slogans. Where ter the had been drowned in its own student in Rockefeller University of over that is just what they are beginning to does the one flow from the other? If the blood the freedom of action, the political Chicago. During the whole period of the do, for recently four comrades were arrested Communists do not raise the slogan of and organizational independence of the Chinese revolution, he was a member and at Tomsk and shipped to Nizhni Sibirsk Establish the power of the Soviets in, Chinese ardent supporter of the Kuo Min Tang, and They would like to finish us off for the let us say; Turkey, does this indicate the On the very eve of the moment that an opponent of Communism. After the Sixteenth council.
absence o: a revolutionary perspective? Or, Chiang Kai Shek was entering Shanghai defeat of the revolution, he joined the Com How is your letter of November conwith his army to let Joose a horrible reign conversely when the sualinists, breaking munist Party and was forth with gent to cerning the possible or inevitable conceswith all the teachings of Marxism and Len.
of terror against the Chinese workers, Stathe Far Eastern University in Moscow to sions to the class enemy in the realizatdon of inism and the experiences of the revolutionfn. was crushing the Opposition in Moscow absorb the latest brand of Stalinism. Fear the Five Year Plan to be interpreted?
because it declared that Chiang would ary movement, carry thru in China a policy legs revolutionist that he was, he resisted What concessions are you speaking about?
of Communist Makhnolsm, of adventurist, soon show himsel, to be the Chinese Galliviolently the proposals that he go to China Up to where will these concessions go?
tet. Stalin then declared that we will still self exhausting guerilla warfare, does that for Communist work, calculating that a head Perhaps you will write us in detall your op.
prove these perverters of Marxism to be on the shoulders in Moscow is worth two inion on this matter.
TO long way with Chiang Kai Shek it would be very the best revolutionists. March 1927. At the moment that Chiang on the ground in Canton. He even wanted useful.
As for me, personally, it seems Kal Shek was beginning the slaughter of So that Doonging conscious falsifcato quit the Far Eastern University to re that being given the situation, after all the the Shanghal proletariat the French Com tion of Trotsky positin may be adequately turn to comfortable America. He was Centrist madness in the country, the return munist Party sent the K, telegram understood we quote from the latter ar foally granted his heart desire. To per to the positions of our Platform runs the greeting the entry into Shanghai as the ticle, China and the Constitueat Assun fect his 100 percent Bolshevik education risk of being interpreted as a concession. Chinese Commune.
bly. Stalin style) he entered Murray Butler But since since they cannot go further, 4. When the Hankow government of Trotsky on the Constituent Columbla University where he is now com am for such a concession, that is, for the Wang Chin Wel and Co. was formed, Stalin China is not passing through a revopleting his studies In Marxism, we sup recall of the measures which have led to the praised it as the only revolutionary cenpose. In the cozy calm of the university generalized mess. mean the generalized tution now but rather a counter revolution.
ter as the organizer of the agrarian revcampus, is he not just the man selected collectivization accompanied by accusatory During such a period, the slogan of Soviets olution (no less. only to have it appear by destiny to teach the Opposition the fun comments.
can have meaning only for restricted cadres in its full stature of strangler of the prodamentals of Marx and Lenin? am against the switching of small by preparing them for the third Chinese letariat and peasantry a brief few weeks agriculture on to the socialist ralls in revolutior in the future. This preparatlou later. The Opposition again demanded in one or two years, because believe that obviously has an enormous importance. To time. break with the Wang Chin Weis such a switching will yield absolutely no.
accomplish it, the slogan of Soviets must and the formation of Soviets, thing and because think the theory of acompany that of the proletariat strugglo Stalin concealed the crying facts socialism in one country is false. am for the dictatorship at the head of all tho of the suppresion of the labor and trade against the monstrosities accomplished by poor masses of the population, and above the Mght hearted Centrists in the country, unior movement in China, the curbing of all, of the poor peaganta. But, besides the (CLARITY)
which make the Kulak a martyr for the the peasant sections, so as not to antag.
preparation by theory and propaganda of onize, first Chiag, then Feng Yu Hsiang, the revolutionary cadres for the revolution MONTHLY ORGAN IN THE JEW. peasant cause. In a word, am for the finally Wang Chin Wel. The Opposition had ary future, there still remains the question ISH LANGUAGE OF THE EFT concession that would consist in a return to make these facts public in secret and COMMUNIST OPPOSITIOX to the position of our Platform, of mobilizing as broad as passible workers Is that illegal documents.
circles for active participation in the po This 16 page paper is of special the kind of concession you speak of in your Stalin and Bucharin sent telegrams November letter? Write us about it litical life of the period we are traversing. interest to all Jewish speaking to the Chinese Communists demanding that This is not inderstood at all by the workers) Number is al. Note of the Editors: That it exactly. the brakes be put upon the peasants more.
Stalinists. For their criminal opportunism ready out ond contains: mont. The Opposition demanded that it be of yesterday they substitute an equally Lenin Testament, arNTW YORK Thousands waited in lige from 11 to a. and broke glass driven forward in collaboration with the criminal adventurism today. With the ticles by Leon Trotdoors at civil service commission offices revolutionary movement in the cities.
working class crushed, the revolutionary sky, Senin, to sign up for street cleaning obs at Chinese Soviets: Now and Then movement decapitated, the order of the day Obin, Emil. a day that will nou materialize for a year. The official brakemen of the Chlis headed, for them, by the. immediate and others Dese revolution opposed the formation of struggle for power, Tes Cents Copy Read the announcement on page two Soviets when the revolutionary wave was But not even for that! The Chinese One Dollar a Year of this issue on the campaign for subscriprising and raised, instead, the slogan of The Opposition proletariat has been forbidden to fight for Order from a constituent assembly.
tions to the Militant. You can help your.
power by the leaders of the Comintern.
The Militant selt to get a free copy of Trotsky autowas for the formation of Soviets, at the China, says Doonping, the task of the mo25 Third Avenue, New York, biography or two other books of vital interproper time, when it meant setting tens ment is the struggle for the democratic est Ly helping the Militant. Read it over of millions of workers and peasants into motion for the capture of power.
dictatorship of the proletarlat and peasantand ACT!
KLORKEIT